My Games
New Games
Top Games

EGM Review:
Battlefield 4 (Next-Gen)

Posted on November 15, 2013 AT 02:15pm

The Art of War

I’ve always had my philosophical differences with Battlefield. There’s at least one moment every match when I wish, if only briefly, that DICE did things differently. Sometimes I get pinned down by enemy armor with nothing in my loadout that can do even a single point of damage to it, and I wish they weren’t so dedicated to their hard counters. Sometimes my teammates take all the vehicles, leaving me to trudge all the way to the next objective, and I wish the maps weren’t quite so sprawling. Sometimes I have a phenomenal round, only to lose because my team wasn’t pulling their weight, and I wish I didn’t feel like such an insignificant cog in the machine.

But then there are the other moments, the ones when I find myself taken in by the sheer scope of it all. I hear the distant gunfire of an infantry ambush. I see the air battle unfolding overhead. I flinch as a tank shell whizzes past my position. I’m suddenly keenly aware of the spectacle unfolding before me, and, for all our disagreements, I’m happy with Battlefield just the way it is.

The Next-Gen Factor

Aside from the higher player cap and larger maps, the only real distinction between the current and next-gen versions of Battlefield 4 is graphical. Like many cross-gen games we’ve seen so far, Battlefield 4 doesn’t quite look as good as you might expect from a new generation of hardware. Some textures look slightly muddy upon close inspection, and the anti-aliasing, while lightyears ahead of the Xbox 360 and PS3 version, is still not as good as on PC or PS4 first-party exclusives, causing distant, thin objects to shimmer.

A few key areas do manage to impress, though. Character’s faces, for example, are quite detailed and expressive, and the higher fidelity of particle effects increase the impact of explosions and destruction considerably.

More than anything else, that’s the feeling DICE has zeroed in on with Battlefield 4. The tradition of grand, awe-inspiring battles is bolstered by a more approachable and varied unlock system, better-designed maps, and, of course, the so-called “levolution” moments, which allow you to make changes to the environment, both large and small. And, of course, Commander mode makes its much-heralded return, giving one player a god’s-eye view of the match and enabling them to support their team with new abilities like support UAVs and supply drops. All these tweaks do wonders to complement the franchise’s established strong suits, namely remarkable sound design, smooth gunplay, and graphics that push the limits of the hardware. This is one of those rare occasions where the longtime sequel mantras of “bigger” and “more” actually pay dividends, strengthening the core appeal of Battlefield without ever feeling unnecessary or bloated.

But there are, as always, a few noticeable shortcomings and flaws. To anyone buttered up by all the pre-release hype, the “levolution” moments might be a slight disappointment. While the impact they have on gameplay is indeed significant—little things like closing doors to shut down routes opens up a surprising amount of new strategies, and larger alterations like collapsing a skyscraper or instigating a flood can dramatically shift the landscape and tone of combat—they’re not quite as dynamic as I’d have hoped. They’re more like a massive switch that can be flipped, but only if you make a concerted effort to do so. Taking out a cracked levee or bringing down the support beams to level a building requires several lives worth of explosives, to the point where it seems unlikely to ever happen by accident. That’s a bit of a letdown, given that Battlefield, with its destruction and combat variety, has always thrived on unexpected emergence.

The larger, 64-player games of Conquest, exclusive to next-gen and PC, are also something of a mixed bag. When everything is working exactly as it should, they have the potential to offer even grander combat scenarios, with tanks, infantry, and aircraft duking it out all around you.

But because the maps are expanded geographically, with new combat areas and capture points, there are moments when it feels like getting to your objective or finding a firefight is even more drawn out and tedious if you don’t have ready access to a vehicle. As a result, these bigger matches tend to lose all appeal when there are fewer than, say, 40 players connected to a server. At the time of writing, I’ve been unable to get into a match that’s even half full with my retail copy of the game. This situation will likely improve as DICE fixes some of the day-one issues they appear to be having, like difficulty connecting to servers and frequent mid-match disconnects, but for the time being, it’s a definite concern.

And, of course, those aforementioned frustrations haven’t gone anywhere. You’ll still get into infuriating death spirals where you curse balance decisions and design choices. You’ll still find that some maps just don’t mesh well with particular game modes or play styles.

But, hot damn, once Battlefield 4 gets into its groove, it’s a force to be reckoned with. When your team starts working together, when you discover the perfect loadout, when you’re on a level that’s perfectly paired to its game type, everything comes together in an incredibly rewarding, almost majestic symphony of systemic complexity. Spend a few hours online, and you’ll have dozens of memorable, thrilling experiences the likes of which just aren’t possible in any other shooter.

I only wish the same could be said for the single-player campaign, which spends just about all of its five-hour running time trying to hammer home how serious and emotional it is. There are serious actors, like Omar from The Wire and also Joey Lawrence’s little brother, for some reason. Characters feel serious things, like empathy and nausea and the desire to shout at each other. They have serious conversations about their emotions and personal backstories. Sometimes people whose names you know die while music written in a very serious minor key swells to a crescendo.

All of these tactics are as painfully transparent as they sound. It’s like they forced a robot to watch every tear-jerking war film ever made, then had him try and piece together a script of his own. He’s going through all the requisite motions, sure, but there’s not a shred of genuine humanity or artistry behind them. Silly Battlefield screenwriting robot, your heart is made of metal and circuits. You cannot love.

To be clear, Battlefield 4’s campaign does make better use of the franchise’s combat principles than DICE’s past three single-player experiences. The AI is greatly improved, the encounters are more skillfully designed, and the ability to tag enemies and direct your squadmates’ attacks on specific targets adds a very light tactical layer to combat. On the whole, however, the linear traipse from one repetitive gunfight to the next punctuated by vehicle segments and ham-handed attempts at storytelling fails to capture any of what makes Battlefield special.

Still, for as much as I don’t want to make excuses, single-player is hardly Battlefield 4’s focus. Even if you watched every TV commercial and read every hands-on preview—hell, even if you looked at the back of the box—you’d be hard-pressed to notice that the campaign even exists. I mean, this is probably the only game I’ve ever seen where the single-player content is relegated to the second disc. EA and DICE clearly want to put multiplayer front and center here—and rightfully so.

Without question, that main attraction proves itself a worthwhile endeavor, strong enough to almost completely overshadow the lackluster single-player offering. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a newcomer trying to decide whether to make this your first go, rest assured, where it truly counts, this is Battlefield doing what it does best, better than ever before.

Developer: DICE • Publisher: EA • ESRB: M – Mature • Release Date: 10.29.2013
Anyone hoping that Battlefield would finally get a respectable single-player campaign will be sorely disappointed, but if you’re looking for a worthy evolution of the franchise’s sweeping multiplayer battles, you’ve come to the right place.
The Good Improvements on just about everything that makes the multiplayer great.
The Bad A single-player campaign that misses its narrative ambitions by a mile.
The Ugly Every time I write “levolution,” I die a little inside.
The next-gen version of Battlefield 4 is available on Xbox One, PlayStation 4, and PC. Primary version reviewed was for PlayStation 4.
Josh Harmon, Associate Editor
Josh Harmon picked up a controller when he was 3 years old—and he hasn't looked back since. This has made him particularly vulnerable to attacks from behind. He joined EGM as an intern following a brief-but-storied career on a number of small gaming blogs across the Internet. Follow him on Twitter @jorshy. Meet the rest of the crew.

Partner Pages


8840 Wilshire Blvd.,
Third Floor,
Beverly Hills, CA 90211

© 2015 EGM Media LLC. All rights reserved. Trademarks belong to their respective owners.
Website Interface © 2012 EGM Digital Media, LLC.